New cedar privacy fence along a sidewalk in Bentonville, AR

Cedar or Pine for a Privacy Fence: How to Choose

Guide

Free Quote
Kismet Fence BBB Business Review
American Fence Association member badge
Bentonville Area Chamber of Commerce logo
Farmington Chamber of Commerce logo
Bella Vista Business Association logo

Pick cedar if you want a wood that resists rot on its own, stays straighter over the seasons and has a richer color. Pick pressure-treated pine if keeping the cost down matters most, because it still makes a solid fence.

Both are wood privacy fences we build across Northwest Arkansas, and both go up the same way. The real differences are how the wood behaves, how it looks as it ages, and what you want to spend up front. Here is how to sort it out.

What cedar gives you

Cedar carries natural oils that help it resist rot and insects. It is also lighter and more stable than pine, so the boards tend to stay straighter as the weather changes. The color starts out warm.

Cedar costs more up front than pressure-treated pine. What you get for the difference is a wood that holds its shape well and looks richer from day one.

One build detail matters with cedar. Its natural tannins react with ordinary steel and leave dark streaks down the boards. That is why we nail every cedar picket with stainless steel nails.

New cedar privacy fence along a sidewalk in Bentonville, AR
New cedar privacy fence along a sidewalk in Bentonville, AR
Pressure-treated pine shadowbox privacy fence with a gate around a back yard in Bentonville, AR
Pressure-treated pine shadowbox privacy fence with a gate around a back yard in Bentonville, AR

What pine gives you

Pressure-treated pine is lumber infused with preservatives under pressure, so it holds up against rot, fungus and insects. It is one of the most common fence woods you see around Northwest Arkansas, and it is the option that keeps the cost down.

Pine is a good choice when the budget comes first. We build it with the same care as cedar, using galvanized nails that stand up to the chemicals in treated lumber.

Know two things going in. Fresh treated pine often looks greenish and still holds moisture from the treatment. And as it dries, the pickets shrink a little.

How each one ages

Left unfinished, cedar weathers to a soft silver-gray. If you like that look, you can skip the stain. If you want to keep more of the warm color, a stain or sealer slows the graying down.

Treated pine goes through a different change. The green tint fades to a light tan, then slowly weathers toward gray. If you plan to stain it, you have to wait until it dries out. That can take anywhere from a few weeks to a few months depending on the weather. A quick test: sprinkle water on a board. If it soaks in, the wood is ready for stain. If it beads up, wait longer.

Shrinking pickets can open thin gaps on a side-by-side fence. If full privacy matters and you are choosing pine, go with board-on-board. Each picket overlaps its neighbors by 1-1/2 inches on each side, so the gaps stay covered.

Questions that settle it

Run through these before you decide.

  • Is keeping the cost down the top priority? Pine is the way to go, and it still makes a solid fence.
  • Do you want boards that stay straight and a richer look from the start? Cedar is built for that.
  • Do you want to stain soon after the fence goes up? Cedar is easier on the timeline. Pine has to dry first.
  • Is privacy with no gaps the goal? Either wood works with board-on-board. It matters more with pine.
  • Do you like a weathered silver look? Cedar gets there on its own if you leave it unfinished.

Whichever wood you choose, the build is the same. Dog-ear tops are standard. Every gate gets a metal frame and metal posts so it does not sag. Our lifetime workmanship warranty covers the work, and the materials carry their manufacturers' warranties. You can also upgrade to PostMaster steel posts, which will not rot, crack or lean the way wood posts eventually can.

Six feet is the usual backyard privacy height. Before you settle on a height, check your town's limits in our fence permit guide, and check with your HOA if you have one. If your town requires a permit, we pull it for you.

Get the real numbers for your yard

What a fence costs depends on the length, the height, the style, how many gates you need and whether an old fence has to come out. The wood you pick is one piece of that. For a rough number in about a minute, draw your fence in the fence calculator.

For a firm answer, book a free on-site quote. We measure the fence line, go over cedar and pine with you, and put the written quote together from there. You can price both woods on the same fence and decide with real numbers in front of you.

Questions we hear

Will my cedar fence turn gray?

Yes. Left unfinished, cedar weathers to a soft silver-gray. A stain or sealer slows that down and keeps more of the warm color, and staining is one of the options we offer when we build your fence.

When can I stain a pine fence?

Once the wood has dried out, which can take anywhere from a few weeks to a few months depending on the weather. Sprinkle some water on a board. If it soaks in, the wood is ready for stain. If it beads up, give it more time.

Danny JohnsonOwner, Kismet Fence

Danny Johnson owns Kismet Fence, a licensed fence contractor based in Farmington, Arkansas (Arkansas Home Improvement License No. 0446811126). He has lived in Northwest Arkansas his whole life, and he reads and approves every post on this blog.

Ready to talk about your fence?

We come out, measure, and give you a written quote, usually the same day. Want a ballpark first? Try the fence calculator.

Schedule a free quoteTry the fence calculator
Book a quote Text Call Email
Kismet Fence👋Hi! Have a question about a fence? Ask away, or book a free on-site quote.